County Board to Release Attorney's Opinion from Dyer Investigation

The Leelanau County Board of Commissioners voted this week to release part of the attorney’s opinion that led the county to separate from former administrator Jim Dyer. The decision followed months of efforts, both on the board and from local residents, to shine more light on the behind-the-scenes circumstances of Dyer’s exit.

The Leelanau Ticker reported last week that the county board was considering a Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) appeal from county resident Gary Hosking, who was seeking documentation around the investigation that triggered Dyer’s exit. The board had placed Dyer on paid administrative leave and hired an outside law firm to conduct an investigation after a June whistleblower complaint from former Finance Director Rio Risbridger blasted Dyer for “a pattern of conduct…that constitutes financial misconduct, circumvention of board authority, and a pattern of intimidation.”

That investigation led the board to vote unanimously to separate from Dyer in August, a decision framed as a “mutual separation agreement.” Almost all conversations about Dyer’s leave and exit happened in closed session, and much of the documentation is covered by attorney-client privilege and has not been publicly released – raising questions about what the investigation found and why the board voted to pay Dyer nearly $70,000 to leave.

Shortly after Dyer’s departure, commissioner Alan Campbell pushed his fellow board members to release “the final investigation and legal opinion regarding our former administrator.” That motion failed 2-5, with only Commissioner Will Bunek also in support.

But the board has now reversed course, voting at their Tuesday meeting to release the “last-two pages” of “the attorney’s opinion of the investigation and our response, dated July 9, 2026.” Vice Chair Mark Walter made that motion at Tuesday’s meeting, with Campbell, Bunek, and Board Chair Steve Yoder voting in support. The three Democrats on the commission – Rick Robbins, Ty Wessell, and Gwenne Allgaier – were opposed.

“I would say we have not released anything beyond what the law required us to release, so we’ve not taken a step towards being open,” Campbell said Tuesday in an argument for the document’s release. “We’ve only done what we had to do, and then pretended that that was going to explain our actions.”

Campbell said he thinks what is currently missing from the public record “is the extent of liability that this county faced” in potentially keeping Dyer employed. The attorney’s opinion, he argued, would shine some new light on that facet of the behind-closed-doors deliberations.

“The impression is that we’re hiding something, and I’ve got nothing to hide,” Campbell said. “I don’t think anyone here has anything to hide.”

Wessell and Allgaier both argued against the release of the legal opinion, worrying it would compromise the privacy and confidentiality of the investigation. That process involved interviews with many county employees.

“I believe the public has a right to know that complaints were taken seriously, that appropriate procedures were followed, and that the board addressed the matters before it,” Wessell said in a written statement he read to the rest of the board. “However, I also believe that there are important limits to what should be made public when personnel matters are involved. Having reviewed the purpose and scope of this document, I believe it goes beyond the information the public needs to know. Releasing the summary risks disclosing personal information that I believe should remain confidential.”

Allgaier “wholeheartedly” agreed with Wessell, arguing that releasing this document could violate the trust the county has with its current and past personnel – including, presumably, Dyer himself.

“When we hire people, I would hope that they can trust that their persons will be honored, that their rights will be honored. I think this is a betrayal of trust, and I don’t think it’s necessary to go further than the hundreds of pages that have already been released,” Allgair said. “And if we do that, there are many things in that attorney opinion that I disagree with.”

Yoder proved to be the swing vote on the matter. The board chair had voted against the release of the legal opinion when Campbell first broached the subject in August, stating that he believed in “protecting the integrity of the investigation” and preserving the privacy and confidentiality of “those that were interviewed. Yoder raised those same concerns last week, but said reviewing the document again in light of the proposed disclosure had alleviated those worries.

“It satisfied my mind in the fact that employees’ identities or comments were protected and were not exposed,” Yoder said. “So, I don’t have an issue with releasing [this document] to satisfy some of the concerns, and hopefully move on from this situation. I’ll support it for that reason.”

Yoder will now “work with legal” to prepare the partial document for release, as a response to Hosking’s FOIA appeal. Allgaier had argued for significant redactions to the document, but her motion received no support.

“I appreciate the four commissioners who took a meaningful step toward helping our community move forward,” Hosking said in a written statement provided to The Ticker. “Taxpayers and county employees deserve to understand the findings that led to the board’s unanimous decisions regarding Dyer’s departure. My understanding is that the board voted to release a portion of outside counsel’s opinion, not the full opinion, and there may be redactions. Until I see what is released, I won’t know if it adequately addresses the questions raised in my appeal. But I’m grateful and encouraged that four commissioners recognized the importance of providing some answers.”