Former Finance Director Sues Leelanau County Board Chair
Former Leelanau County Finance Director Cathy Hartesvelt has filed a defamation lawsuit against Steve Yoder, chair of the Leelanau County Board of Commissioners. The filing, which was shared with The Leelanau Ticker by Hartesvelt’s attorney Blake Ringsmuth, claims Yoder falsely accused Hartesvelt of criminal activity while in a public space, and that his comments were subsequently repeated and spread around Leelanau County as fact.
The lawsuit alleges Yoder attended an “informal meeting” at Art’s Tavern in Glen Arbor “on or about January 12, 2026,” where, “apropos of nothing being discussed at the time,” he “stated as fact that [Hartesvelt] was engaged in an illegal conspiracy to cover up financial corruption being perpetrated by her and the county clerk.” Yoder allegedly said the conspiracy “had been going on for some time.”
Hartesvelt had previously worked as deputy county clerk under longtime Clerk Michelle Crocker. Crocker did not respond to a request for comment.
The Art’s Tavern meeting was “attended by a number of private individuals who were Leelanau County residents,” the lawsuit states. The filing does not identify those individuals by name or description, other than to say they were “shocked and upset” about Yoder’s accusations and asked why he wasn’t doing anything to hold Hartesvelt and Crocker accountable. Yoder reportedly said he “did not have the support of other county commissioners to deal with the alleged illegality.”
The lawsuit also claims Yoder told the group he was aware of additional illegal behavior perpetrated by Hartesvelt, but couldn’t share details due to his standing as a member of the Board of Commissioners.
Because the purported January 12 meeting took place in a public setting, Hartesvelt’s lawsuit says Yoder's accusations against her “were overheard by members of the public beyond just those attending the meeting.” Those accusations then spread throughout Leelanau County.
The suit denies the claims of conspiracy and illegality as “unequivocally false and without any basis in fact whatsoever,” and accuses Yoder of making those statements “with actual malice knowing they were false.” Further, the suit suggests Yoder made those claims as a way “to garner support from the group for [Hartesvelt’s] eventual firing,” which the suit claims had been “previously planned with the county administrator, among others.”
Jim Dyer, the county administrator at the time, had placed Hartesvelt on paid leave on Friday, January 9, three days before Yoder’s alleged meeting at Art’s Tavern. Dyer fired Hartesvelt one month later, citing insubordination.
Because of the alleged malice involved, the lawsuit argues Yoder’s “allegations of illegality” against Hartesvelt “constitute defamation per se pursuant to MCL 600.2911(1).” Hartesvelt is seeking a jury trial and damages “in excess of $25,000.”
Asked for comment on the lawsuit, Yoder said in an email Tuesday that The Ticker was “the first to notify me that I’m being sued,” and that he had not “even been served yet.”
“If and when I’m served, I intend to vigorously defend myself in court, and out of respect for the legal process, I will not comment on this matter any further outside of court,” Yoder wrote.
Yoder is the lone defendant in the lawsuit. The county as a legal entity is not implicated, and no other county commissioners are mentioned in the filing. However, a press release issued by Ringsmuth adds context by suggesting the suit should raise “serious questions about a troubling pattern of retaliation against employees who have reported improper conduct by Leelanau County officials.”
“Within the past year, several complaints concerning the former county administrator’s conduct prompted an investigation by an independent law firm,” the press release notes, referring to grievances filed against Dyer by former account clerk Elizabeth Gray and former county finance director Rio Risbridger. “Following that investigation, the County Board of Commissioners voted unanimously to remove the administrator. Yet despite the investigation’s substantiation of the complaints, certain commissioners have directed blame toward the women who reported the misconduct rather than the conduct that led to the administrator’s removal. One commissioner went so far as to state that the former administrator ‘got screwed’ by the whistleblower.”
Risbridger called out Gwenne Allgaier, the commissioner who made the “got screwed” comment, last month when she addressed the board after resigning as finance director.
“Commissioner Allgaier, you made that statement to the Leelanau Enterprise after the law firm this board retained concluded that [Dyer] likely violated the law,” Risbridger said. “I reported him because it was the right thing to do. Your statement in support of him came after the report concluded that I was the victim.”
Risbridger also alleged she had been subject to consistent retaliation by commissioners after filing her complaint against Dyer, including having her “movements and leave” tracked, her conversations reported back to commissioners, and her work criticized “in the open and in the press.”
Hartesvelt had also filed a grievance against Dyer last year, but the Board of Commissioners cleared the former administrator of any wrongdoing in October 2025. Hartesvelt was placed on leave three months later.
“When employees report improper conduct, government’s responsibility is to investigate their concerns, not contrive ways to get rid of them,” Ringsmuth said in the press release announcing the lawsuit.