Just How Big Was the First Month at the Sugar Loaf Scenic Area?
At least 5,000 people cycled through the new Sugar Loaf Scenic Area in its first month open to the public, Leelanau Conservancy representatives tell The Leelanau Ticker. All the traffic has immediately made Sugar Loaf one of the most popular properties in the Leelanau Conservancy portfolio – though, it hasn’t come without challenges.
The Leelanau Conservancy announced on September 27 that the Sugar Loaf Scenic Area would be marking its grand opening with a special event on the evening of Friday, October 9. That announcement followed more than a year of fundraising and behind-the-scenes work at Sugar Loaf, with anticipation for the public opening growing by the day after the Conservancy announced in July of 2025 that it would be acquiring 285 acres of the long-dormant ski resort property. Sugar Loaf had closed for good in 2000, and the intervening 25 years had been dotted with broken promises and false hope about the property becoming a publicly accessible asset once more.
Speaking to The Leelanau Ticker a week before the grand reopening, Becky Hill, natural areas director for the Leelanau Conservancy, said the nonprofit had already received roughly 600 RSVPs for the event. The Conservancy later reported in an email newsletter that the grand opening had seen “over a thousand community members make their way to the summit” of Sugar Loaf.
Asked for a full first-month report from the Loaf, Conservancy Communications Director Brighid Driscoll and the Conservancy’s stewardship staff shared the following statistics about traffic, volunteer work, and conservation efforts at the property.
4,882: The number of visitors clocked by the Sugar Loaf Scenic Area’s trail counters between October 9 and November 9, “including 443 on opening day,” Driscoll says. Comparatively, Clay Cliffs Natural Area, historically the most popular property in the Leelanau Conservancy portfolio, tracked 2,066 trail counts for the month of October.
99: Volunteers who lent a hand at the new scenic area in the first month. Among other responsibilities, those volunteers helped plant 138 new trees and shrubs at the property and got nine different native wildflower species “frost seeded.”
35: Hikes taken at Sugar Loaf by one particularly busy Conservancy volunteer, Karen Rennie, since the Scenic Area opened.
How do those traffic numbers compare to what is typical for Leelanau Conservancy properties?
Consider that, in 2020, when the COVID-19 pandemic triggered a historic spike in trail usage across Leelanau Conservancy natural areas and preserves, the nonprofit tallied a total of 102,294 hikers for the full year. That number equates to an average of 8,525 trail users per month for the entire Leelanau Conservancy portfolio, which at the time spanned 28 natural areas and preserves.
Clay Cliffs notched 20,726 trail users in 2020, for a monthly average of 1,727 visitors; traffic numbers at that natural area had nearly tripled compared to 2019, according to the Conservancy’s 2020 annual report. Whaleback Natural Area, the second most popular Conservancy property, had just over 16,000 trail users in 2020, or about 1,336 per month.
The massive popularity of Sugar Loaf has had one drawback, which the Leelanau Conservancy lamented in a September 21 Facebook post.
“We've been so happy that folks are enjoying the newly opened Sugar Loaf Scenic Area and hiking to the top for those beautiful views,” the post said. “Unfortunately, there have been some not-so-great views near the bathrooms and parking area. When someone leaves bags of dog poop or baby diapers behind, our staff is stuck taking care of it. More importantly, because picking up litter and waste takes valuable time away from our stewardship staff's work, we don't provide trash cans at our Natural Areas. We want our team laser-focused on great trails, restoring wildlife habitats, and protecting the ecology that makes Leelanau so special.”
The post concluded by asking visitors to the new Sugar Loaf Scenic Area to “follow Leave No Trace principles,” including bagging and carrying out any and all trash.
Despite that hiccup, Leelanau Conservancy Executive Director Tom Nelson was nothing but effusive when asked for his reaction to the busy first month.
“After 26 years, seeing people back at Sugar Loaf has meant so much to all of us,” Nelson says. “This first month, we’ve been hearing people’s memories, watching families explore together, and seeing smiles on faces of every age. It took years of work and tremendous community support to get here, and now we’re seeing what that effort means in people’s everyday lives. There’s more work ahead, but giving people a place to reconnect with the land and each other is a pretty wonderful start.”
The “more work” Nelson is talking about includes plans for more trails, as well as family-friendly amenities like a sledding hill, a seasonal ice rink, and a native plant garden. Sugar Loaf Scenic Area launched with just one trail: the “Summit Trail,” which allows visitors to hike to the top of the mountain.