Rio Risbridger Sues Rick Robbins for Defamation
For the second time this week, a Leelanau County commissioner has been hit with a defamation lawsuit.
Just days after former county finance director Cathy Hartesvelt filed suit against Board Chair Steve Yoder, another former finance director, Rio Risbridger, has brought a similar lawsuit against commissioner Rick Robbins.
The lawsuit concerns the claim Robbins made at a late September budget meeting, that Risbridger was trying to manipulate staffing levels in the county's building and grounds department in hopes of getting her husband a better job. Risbridger’s husband has previously served as a seasonal employee in that department. The accusation, which The Ticker asked Robbins about following the September meeting, ultimately led Risbridger to resign her position with the county.
Now, Risbridger is suing Robbins over that allegation, claiming it rises to the level of defamation. Risbridger is represented in the case by Blake Ringsmuth of the Traverse City-based law firm Ringsmuth Wuori PLLC, the same lawyer and firm representing Hartesvelt in her claim against Yoder. Risbridger is seeking “the recovery of compensatory and other damages” in excess of $25,000, also the same dollar amount Hartesvelt is seeking. Both lawsuits demand a trial by jury.
“On or about September 29, 2026, [Risbridger] and [Robbins] were in attendance at a Leelanau County budget meeting,” the lawsuit states. “One of the issues to be discussed was the consolidation of certain job positions within the County related to, among other things, the County's facilities. Such consolidation was approved by the County Commission at a prior meeting.”
During a break in the meeting, Robbins got into an argument with fellow commissioner Will Bunek, in which he “accused [Risbridger] of illegally manipulating the relevant budget to financially benefit herself. Specifically, so that Plaintiff's husband could gain full-time employment with the County.” The lawsuit suggests that Robbins made the allegation as “a statement of fact and not mere opinion,” and that Robbins “claimed to have personal knowledge of [Risbridger’s] alleged illegal plan.”
“Such financial impropriety by [Risbridger], were it true, would be a crime under Michigan law,” the lawsuit notes, adding that the accusation “was shocking and extremely upsetting to [Risbridger] and…others who heard [Robbins’] statement.” Those “others” include other members of the Board of Commissioners, county residents in attendance at the budget session, and anyone who subsequently viewed the meeting recording, which is “saved and viewable on YouTube.”
“Within a day or two of making the accusation against [Risbridger], [Robbins] again made the same accusation of [Risbridger’s] alleged illegal conduct to a journalist,” the lawsuit continues, referring to a conversation between Robbins and The Ticker, which the suit describes as “a widely read publication in the surrounding area.”
“In turn, on October 2, 2026, the journalist contacted [Risbridger] and repeated [Robbins’] accusation of her alleged illegal conduct indicating he was going to run a story to include [Robbins’] accusation,” the lawsuit continues. “The fact that a journalist was likely going to publish [Robbins’] defamatory accusation against [Risbridger] further horrified her.”
Risbridger resigned shortly after that phone call with The Ticker.
The story in question, titled “Disarray at the Leelanau County Government Center: Budgeting Session Spurs Criminal Complaint, Finance Director Resignation,” was published by The Ticker on October 5. It recounts the events of the previous week’s budget session, including Robbins’ on-camera allegation against Risbridger and his subsequent argument with Bunek. As that article states, Risbridger declined to comment on Robbins’ accusations against her when reached by The Ticker shortly after 4pm on Friday, October 2. Roughly an hour later, Interim County Administrator Lauren Cypher informed The Ticker that Risbridger had tendered her resignation shortly before 5pm that afternoon, effective immediately.
“I can categorically deny the allegation from Commissioner Robbins that this change came from Rio Risbridger,” Cypher said of the staffing shakeup in the building and grounds department. “The only part she had in it was working up the budget impact. I can say Rio’s husband is a seasonal employee, so he would be eligible to apply for that position, should he be interested.”
The lawsuit states that the allegations brought against Risbridger by Robbins “are patently and unequivocally false and without any basis in fact whatsoever,” and accuses Robbins of making those allegations “with actual malice knowing they were false and/or with reckless disregard of their falsity.”
“[Robbins’] malice toward [Risbridger] stems, in part, from her prior ‘whistleblowing’ related to misconduct of the former County Administrator whom [Robbins] supported,” the lawsuit claims, referring to Risbridger’s complaint against former administrator Jim Dyer. “[Risbridger's allegations of illegality constitute defamation per se pursuant to MCL 600.2911(1). As a direct and proximate result of [Robbins’] defamatory statements, including the broadcast of them by publication, [Risbridger] has been significantly harmed in both reputation and personally, entitling her to all damages allowed by law.”
Addressing the County Commission at a meeting just days after her resignation, Risbridger alleged she had been subject to an escalating pattern of “retaliation” from commissioners following her complaint against Dyer.
“The retaliation was not a single instant or a difficult stretch,” Risbridger said. “It was frequent, it was public, and it did not stop. My movements and leave were tracked. Conversations in my offices were reported to commissioners. My workload increased while I was required to correct the errors that were not my responsibility. My work was criticized, in the open and in the press. I parked at different entrances to avoid being watched, and I lost sleep over potential errors and how they might be used against me.”
Robbins declined to comment when reached by The Ticker Thursday afternoon.